Understanding Partner Violence Among Some Partners in Lesbian Couples

Partner violence within lesbian relationships is a significant issue that has increasingly gained recognition as a critical social concern. Often termed domestic violence or intimate partner violence, it encompasses various forms of abuse, including physical, sexual, and psychological harm. While research has frequently concentrated on physical violence, the multifaceted nature of abuse within lesbian partnerships warrants comprehensive understanding and attention.

How Prevalent is Partner Violence in Lesbian Relationships?

Studies indicate that a notable percentage of lesbians experience partner violence. Reports suggest that between 17% and 45% of lesbians have been victims of at least one instance of physical violence perpetrated by a female partner. These acts of physical abuse can manifest in different ways, with research highlighting specific examples reported by over 10% of participants in one study:

• Disrupting eating or sleeping patterns
• Pushing, shoving, reckless driving to intimidate
• Slapping, kicking, hitting, or biting

Sexual abuse within lesbian relationships is also a serious concern, with studies suggesting that up to 50% of lesbians have reported experiencing sexual abuse from a female partner.

Psychological abuse is alarmingly common, with prevalence rates ranging from 24% to 90% among lesbians, indicating that a significant majority may encounter this form of abuse at least once in their relationships.

It is important to note that much of the existing research has been conducted with specific demographics – predominantly white, middle-class lesbians who are openly lesbian and actively engaged in lesbian communities, making them accessible to researchers. This demographic focus raises questions about the generalizability of these findings to lesbians who may be less open about their sexual orientation, have different socioeconomic backgrounds, or belong to diverse ethnic groups. Further research is needed to understand the nuances of partner violence across the lesbian community.

Motivations Behind Violence Among Some Partners in Lesbian Couples

Understanding why some lesbians perpetrate violence against their partners requires exploring complex motivations that, in some ways, mirror those observed in heterosexual male batterers. A primary driver for abusive behavior in lesbian relationships is the desire to exert and maintain control over their partner. This need for control can stem from deep-seated fears of loss and abandonment, leading to violent episodes particularly when separation is threatened or perceived.

Furthermore, the backgrounds of lesbian batterers often reveal a history of exposure to violence. Many individuals who perpetrate violence in lesbian relationships grew up in households where violence was present. They may have personally experienced physical, sexual, or verbal abuse, or witnessed their mothers being abused by fathers or stepfathers. This intergenerational transmission of violence underscores the profound impact of childhood experiences on adult relationship dynamics.

Similarities and Differences Between Lesbian and Heterosexual Partner Violence

While there are unique aspects to lesbian partner violence, it shares significant similarities with heterosexual partner violence. Notably, the prevalence of violence in lesbian relationships appears to be comparable to that in heterosexual relationships. The cyclical nature of violence, characterized by phases of tension building, violent incidents, and periods of remorse or reconciliation, is also observed in both types of relationships.

However, key differences emerge when examining the dynamics within the relationships and societal factors. In heterosexual relationships, a gendered pattern often exists where male partners are more frequently the perpetrators of violence due to societal power structures and physical advantages. In contrast, lesbian relationships present a more complex picture. The partner who is perceived as more dominant – whether physically stronger, more masculine in presentation, or the primary wage earner – is not automatically the abuser. In fact, research indicates that this “butch” member in lesbian relationships can be as likely to be the victim as the perpetrator. Furthermore, lesbian victims are more likely to report fighting back against their abusers, challenging traditional victim-perpetrator dynamics often seen in heterosexual domestic violence.

A uniquely challenging dimension for lesbians experiencing partner violence is the pervasive homophobic environment. This external pressure creates opportunities for abusive partners to wield “heterosexist control.” Perpetrators may threaten to “out” their partners to family, friends, or employers, leveraging the potential for social and professional repercussions due to their sexual orientation. Threats can also extend to manipulating legal systems, such as jeopardizing child custody, immigration status, or legal standing by making reports to authorities based on homophobic biases. This homophobic context significantly complicates help-seeking for lesbian victims, making them hesitant to approach law enforcement, victim services, or domestic violence shelters due to fear of discrimination or lack of understanding.

Legal Rights and Protections for Battered Lesbians

The legal landscape for lesbian victims of domestic violence is varied and often challenging. In some jurisdictions, laws have evolved to ensure that lesbian domestic violence cases are treated with parity to heterosexual domestic violence. For instance, certain states mandate police to handle lesbian domestic violence incidents in the same way as heterosexual cases, and mandatory arrest laws in some areas apply equally to batterers regardless of sexual orientation. This means that in specific situations, police are legally required to arrest a batterer, whether in a lesbian or heterosexual relationship. Furthermore, lesbian batterers can be prosecuted in criminal courts, and survivors may be eligible for protective orders, legally binding court orders that prevent an abuser from contacting or approaching the victim.

However, significant disparities and gaps in legal protection persist across different regions. Alarmingly, seven states—Arizona, Delaware, Louisiana, Montana, New York, South Carolina, and Virginia—explicitly exclude same-sex couples from obtaining protective orders. Additionally, three states—Florida, Maryland, and Mississippi—often interpret or apply protective order laws in a way that effectively excludes same-sex couples, either by limiting orders to opposite-sex couples or through common legal interpretations. These limitations highlight the ongoing legal vulnerabilities faced by lesbian individuals in abusive relationships in many parts of the country.

Underreporting of Lesbian Partner Violence to the Police

A critical issue compounding the problem of lesbian partner violence is the significant underreporting of incidents to law enforcement. Numerous barriers prevent lesbian victims from seeking help from the police. A primary deterrent is the well-founded fear of prejudicial treatment from law enforcement. Lesbian individuals may anticipate homophobic bias or disbelief, leading to reluctance to report abuse. This fear is exacerbated by the fact that, as previously mentioned, domestic violence laws in many states do not adequately protect same-sex partners, further diminishing confidence in the legal system’s ability to offer support and justice.

Another detrimental factor contributing to underreporting is the common misconception among law enforcement personnel that same-sex violence is often mutual. Police officers may readily assume that in a lesbian domestic violence situation, both partners are equally abusive, or they may be more inclined to believe an abuser’s claim of mutual abuse. This bias can result in both members of a couple being arrested, rather than appropriately identifying and addressing the actual perpetrator and victim dynamic. Furthermore, battered women’s agencies, which are crucial resources for victims of domestic violence, may not always be welcoming or equipped to serve lesbians, creating additional obstacles to accessing support and safety.

How to Support a Lesbian Victim of Partner Violence

Providing effective support to a lesbian who is experiencing partner violence requires understanding and sensitivity to the unique challenges they face. Here are crucial steps to take:

• Offer Open Communication: Let her know unequivocally that she can reach out to you for help whenever she needs it. Creating a safe space for communication is the first step in offering support.

• Develop a Safety Plan: Collaborate with her to create a detailed safety plan. This plan should outline how she can safely leave the abusive situation if necessary. Key components of a safety plan include:

  • Preparing an emergency bag: This bag should be discreetly packed and readily accessible, containing essential documents such as identification, money, and any other items crucial for immediate relocation and safety.
  • Arranging a safe haven: Help her identify and arrange a safe place to stay in case of an emergency. This could be a friend’s house, a family member’s home, or a shelter.
  • Offer practical assistance: Provide concrete help, such as giving her a spare set of house keys, offering temporary accommodation, or assisting with transportation.

• Provide Ongoing Support and Patience: It is vital to be patient and persistent in your support. Do not give up on her, even if she is not ready to leave the abusive relationship immediately. Leaving an abusive situation is a complex and often prolonged process. Avoid criticizing her or turning her away if she chooses to stay in the relationship or returns to it after leaving. Victims often face immense emotional, practical, and societal pressures that influence their decisions.

• Connect to Specialized Resources: If you are in a city or area that has an Anti-Violence Project (AVP) affiliated with the National Coalition of Anti-Violence Programs (http://www.avp.org), inform her about the services they offer. AVPs are specialized organizations that provide crucial support to LGBTQ individuals experiencing violence, including:

  • Counseling services tailored to the needs of lesbian survivors of partner violence.
  • Advocacy and support when interacting with law enforcement and the criminal justice system.
  • Support groups where survivors can connect with others who have similar experiences, fostering a sense of community and reducing isolation.
  • Therapists specializing in lesbian partner abuse: Some therapists specifically focus on addressing partner abuse within lesbian relationships, offering specialized expertise and understanding.

By providing these forms of support, you can play a critical role in helping a lesbian victim of partner violence navigate their situation, access resources, and work towards safety and healing.

---

Sources:

1. Burke, Leslie K., & Follingstad, Diane R. (1999). Violence in lesbian and gay relationships: theory, prevalence, and correlational factors. Clinical Psychology Review, 19 (5), 487-512.
2. Heer, Christine, Grogan, Eileen, Clark, Sandra, & Carson, Lynda M. (1998). Developing services for lesbians in abusive relationships: A macro and micro approach. In A. R. Roberts (Ed.), Battered women and their families: Intervention, strategies, and treatment programs (pp. 365-384). New York: Springer Publishing Company, Inc.
3. Istar, Arlene. (1996). Couple assessment: Identifying and intervening in domestic violence in lesbian relationships. Journal of Gay and Lesbian Social Services, 4 (1), 93-106.
4. Leeder, Elaine. (1994). Treatment of battering in couples: Heterosexual, lesbian, and gay. In Elaine Leeder, Treating abuse in families: A feminist and community approach. New York: Springer Publishing Co.
5. Lie, Gwat-Yong, & Gentlewarrier, Sabrina. (1991). Intimate violence in lesbian relationships: Discussion of survey findings and practice implications. Journal of Social Service Research, 15 (1/2), 41-59.
6. Lie, Gwat-Yong, Schilit, Rebecca, Bush, Judy, Montagne, Marilyn, & Reyes, Lynn. Lesbians in currently aggressive relationships: How frequently do they report aggressive past relationships? Violence and Victims, 6, (2), 121-135.
7. Margolies, Liz, & Leeder, Elaine. (1995). Violence at the door: Treatment of lesbian batterers. Violence against Women, 1 (2), 139-157.
8. Marrujo, Becky, & Keger, Mary. (1995). Definition of roles in abusive lesbian relationships. In Claire M. Renzetti & Charles H. Miley (Eds.), Violence in gay and lesbian domestic partnerships (pp. 23-33). New York: Harrington Park Press.
9. National Coalition of Anti-Violence Programs (http://www.avp.org). (1999). Lesbian, gay, transgender and bisexual domestic violence in 1998. New York: NCAVP. (See also 1997 and 1998 reports for information on state laws concerning same-sex domestic violence.)
10. Ristock, Janice L. (1997). The cultural politics of abuse in lesbian relationships: Challenges for community action. In N. V. Benodraitis (Ed.), Subtle sexism: Current practice and prospects for change (pp. 279-296). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
11. Scherzer, Teresa. (1998). Domestic violence in lesbian relationships: Findings of the lesbian relationships research project. Journal of Lesbian Studies, 2 (1), 29-47.
12. Waldner-Haugrud, Lisa K., & Vaden Gratch, Linda. (1997). Sexual coercion in gay/lesbian relationships: Descriptives and gender differences. Violence and Victims, 12 (1), 87-98.
13. Waldner-Haugrud, Lisa K., Vaden Gratch, Linda, & Magruder, Brian. (1997). Victimization and perpetration rates of violence in gay and lesbian relationships: Gender issues explored. Violence and Victims, 12 (2), 173-184.
14. West, Carolyn M. (1998). Leaving a second closet: Outing partner violence in same-sex couples. In Jana L. Jasinski & Linda M. Williams (Eds.), Partner violence: A comprehensive review of 20 years of research (pp. 163-183). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.