In today’s evolving social landscape, businesses are increasingly recognizing the critical importance of diversity, equity, and inclusion (DE&I). This heightened awareness is driving a necessary examination of systems that have historically limited opportunities for marginalized communities worldwide. For companies aiming to thrive, fostering diverse and inclusive environments is not just a matter of social responsibility, but a strategic imperative. Insight Partners, a leading global venture capital and private equity firm, understands this shift and emphasizes the value of DE&I within its portfolio and the broader tech ecosystem. Resources like Wall Street Oasis (WSO) also reflect the growing importance of DE&I discussions within the finance and business sectors, highlighting the demand for inclusive workplaces.
So, how can companies genuinely attract diverse talent from historically underrepresented groups and cultivate workplaces where these individuals feel valued, empowered, and want to stay long-term?
To address this crucial question, Insight Partners convened a discussion with CEOs from prominent DE&I-focused organizations: Lucinda Duncalfe of AboveBoard, Matt Stephenson of Code2College, John Roussel of Colorwave, and Mike Slagh of Shift. These leaders shared invaluable insights on building representative teams and fostering truly inclusive cultures within scaling companies.
Here are five key takeaways from this insightful conversation, crucial for any ScaleUp looking to build a stronger, more equitable future:
1. Prioritize Core Competencies Over Traditional Credentials in Hiring Practices
Outdated hiring practices often rely heavily on credentials like specific degrees or past employers, inadvertently creating barriers for diverse talent pools. By shifting the focus to core competencies, companies can dismantle these biases and evaluate candidates based on the skills and abilities truly necessary for success in a given role. This competency-based approach opens doors to a wider range of qualified individuals who may have gained their expertise through non-traditional pathways.
Lucinda Duncalfe, CEO of AboveBoard, emphasizes this point: “Go through the process and ask yourself: ‘What are the requirements for this role? What competencies does someone need?’ Don’t just focus on which places they’ve worked. By aligning on these competencies, it enables you to screen candidates against them.” This strategic shift allows for a more equitable evaluation process, ensuring that talent is recognized regardless of their background or pedigree.
Matt Stephenson, CEO of Code2College, further underscores the urgency of this change, particularly in the current competitive job market: “We’re all in a situation right now where the tight labor market has forced us to examine legacy screening tactics – such as looking at specific universities for talent – and to open up that aperture and say, ‘We know that we’re missing out on talent.’ And I do hope that we’re using this moment and sort of stretching it out to change policies more broadly.” This moment of re-evaluation presents a unique opportunity to permanently dismantle biased screening methods and broaden the scope of talent acquisition.
2. Remember Equity and Inclusion are Integral to Diversity
While many companies focus primarily on the “D” in DE&I – diversity, often measured by representation metrics – it’s crucial to recognize that diversity is only one piece of the puzzle. True progress requires a holistic approach that equally emphasizes equity and inclusion. Neglecting these crucial elements can undermine diversity efforts and lead to a revolving door of talent.
Duncalfe cautions against this narrow focus: “They have now turned diversity, equity & inclusion into DE&I, which I think is really unfortunate because they are three different things, three different steps. And when they get bucketed together, we often only think about the first part – diversity – what [people] are.” Simply hiring diverse individuals is insufficient if the workplace environment doesn’t foster a sense of belonging and provide equitable opportunities for growth.
Companies must actively develop strategies that ensure all employees, regardless of their background, feel welcomed, respected, and have equal access to advancement and development opportunities. This commitment to equity and inclusion is paramount for creating a sustainable and thriving diverse workforce.
John Roussel, CEO of Colorwave, highlights the symbiotic relationship between an equitable and inclusive environment and a robust diverse talent pipeline: “At the end of the day, some of the best pipelines are developed by using your people. It’s about maintaining relationships. Once you get someone in the door and you treat them well and you make it an environment where they feel included, they will likely help you develop your pipeline by recruiting other people. It really is about creating an experience and an environment where people feel comfortable, and then those people will help you build and widen the pipeline to bring other people in.” Creating a positive employee experience for diverse hires becomes a powerful engine for attracting even more diverse talent.
3. Lead with Inquiry: Define DE&I Meaningfully for Your Organization
DE&I is not a one-size-fits-all concept. Its meaning and implementation must be tailored to the specific context and values of each organization. Instead of blindly following industry trends, leaders must engage in thoughtful introspection to define what DE&I truly means for their company. This introspective process should involve asking critical questions and deeply understanding the organization’s unique needs and aspirations in the realm of diversity, equity, and inclusion.
Roussel advises, “Companies really need to sit down and think about ‘what is our organization’s vision and definition of equity & inclusion?’ A lot of what you see in the marketplace today is following the leader or what’s trendy around DE&I. But until you’ve done the reflection and understood what that means for the organization that you’re building, you’ll never really get it right.” A genuine commitment to DE&I starts with a clear, internally defined vision that resonates with the company’s core values and strategic goals.
Furthermore, companies should adopt an experimental mindset, embracing a test-and-learn approach to DE&I initiatives. Incremental changes and pilot programs can be more effective than sweeping, disruptive overhauls. Mike Slagh, CEO of Shift, suggests this pragmatic approach: “An amazing initiative can start with one great hire or one teammate who’s empowered to try something new. So having a little bit of time to experiment and say ‘Hey, this is a pilot; we’re going to try this for 5 to 10 hires and see if it moves the needle,’ is key. Change management happens through these projects.” This iterative approach allows for continuous improvement and ensures that DE&I strategies are practical, impactful, and aligned with the organization’s evolving needs.
4. Embrace the Necessary Discomfort of Change
Meaningful progress in DE&I requires confronting uncomfortable truths and challenging existing norms. Discussions around diversity, equity, and inclusion can be sensitive and provoke discomfort, but this discomfort is often a sign of necessary growth and transformation. Avoiding these difficult conversations will only perpetuate the status quo and hinder genuine change.
Stephenson asserts that “If you’re seeking comfort, change cannot happen. If you’re feeling discomfort, that’s a pretty natural thing. It means that you are challenging your own assumptions and belief systems and that’s not a bad thing, because we can all agree that things need to change.” Embracing discomfort as a catalyst for change is essential for dismantling systemic biases and fostering a more inclusive environment.
Slagh further emphasizes the link between discomfort and growth: “Not only can you not change without discomfort, but you can’t grow without discomfort.” Companies must cultivate a culture where employees feel safe engaging in uncomfortable conversations, knowing that these dialogues are crucial for collective learning and progress.
5. Measure Progress and Hold Accountable to DE&I Goals
Like any strategic business objective, DE&I initiatives require clear goals and measurable outcomes. Companies must define what “representative” means for their organization and establish specific, trackable metrics to gauge the effectiveness of their DE&I efforts. Without defined goals and consistent measurement, it becomes difficult to assess progress, identify areas for improvement, and ensure accountability.
Stephenson stresses the importance of clear metrics: “Unless you have outlined what representative means for your org and where you would like to make an impact from the outset, it’s going to be difficult to track whether or not you’re doing well here or hold yourself accountable to your organization’s specific goals.” Establishing transparent metrics and regularly monitoring progress is essential for demonstrating commitment and driving meaningful change.
This data-driven approach not only allows companies to track their DE&I journey but also provides valuable insights into what strategies are working effectively and where adjustments are needed. Accountability, driven by measurable goals, ensures that DE&I remains a priority and not just a performative initiative.
The Path Forward: Intentional Action and Continuous Improvement
Building truly representative and inclusive teams is not a passive endeavor; it demands dedicated effort, thoughtful leadership, and a commitment to continuous improvement. It requires companies to proactively identify and address existing biases, implement inclusive policies, and cultivate a workplace culture where individuals from all backgrounds can thrive. As Matt Stephenson and Mike Slagh aptly point out, change is inherently uncomfortable, but embracing this discomfort is the pathway to growth and the opportunity to make a significant positive impact on both business success and broader societal equity. By focusing on these key principles, companies can move beyond performative gestures and build truly diverse, equitable, and inclusive workplaces that benefit both their employees and their bottom line. For further information on Insight Partners‘ commitment to DE&I and related programs, please reach out to [email protected].
About the Partners
AboveBoard is dedicated to connecting senior executives from underrepresented groups, including Black, Latinx/Hispanic, and women, with exclusive leadership opportunities at high-growth companies.
Code2College is a non-profit organization focused on dramatically increasing the number of historically underserved students who pursue and complete STEM degrees and careers through tuition-free coding education and paid internships.
Colorwave is a non-profit organization working to close the racial wealth gap by connecting rising professionals of color with leadership roles at venture capital-backed startups.
Shift is dedicated to assisting members of the military, both past and present, in discovering new career paths, acquiring relevant skills, and transitioning into meaningful civilian employment.
Diversity, Equity & Inclusion: It Starts with the Four “Cs”
Learn More
